Episode 940: Inside the Breonna Taylor Case – John Mattingly's Unfiltered Perspective

Street Cop Podcast

In this episode of the Street Cop Podcast, Dennis Benigno and co-host Ely Alfonso welcome John Mattingly, the former Louisville Metro Police officer deeply involved in the Breonna Taylor case. John provides a raw and insightful perspective on the shooting and the media’s role in distorting the truth. He discusses the critical importance of vigilance and preparedness, the need for a proactive Public Information Officer, and the challenges posed by body cameras and misinformation. John reflects on how his life was upended by media disinformation, the personal and professional struggles he faced, and what he would change if given another chance. This episode is a must-listen for those interested in understanding the complexities of high-profile cases and the impact of media on law enforcement.

Time Stamps:

00:00:00:00 - 00:01:04:06 Teaser 00:01:04:06 - 00:03:06:15 Intro 00:03:06:15 - 00:21:23:19 John’s background & the Breonna Taylor shooting 00:21:23:19 - 00:24:18:21 Complacency & being prepared 00:24:18:21 - 00:27:40:03 The importance of a proactive Public Information Officer 00:27:40:03 - 00:31:14:18 Lies & body cameras 00:31:14:18 - 00:44:15:11 The misinformation of the media 00:44:15:11 - 00:53:26:24 How John’s life changed after the media’s disinformation 00:53:26:24 - 01:02:38:16 How John managed the struggle 01:02:38:16 - 01:10:41:07 John’s reflection on the shooting: what he’d do differently 01:10:41:07 - 01:44:36:17 Irreparable reputational damage, improper training, & administrative betrayal 01:44:36:17 - 01:47:52:17 Outro