Christification: A Review of Fr. Robert Imbelli's 'Christ Brings All Newness'

The Catholic Thing

By Dominic V. Cassella.
But first a note from Robert Royal: This is the final week for our end-of-year fundraising campaign, and we need one last push to get where we need to be going forward. We all know that 2025 will be an especially challenging year for many reasons in both the Church and the world. Help us to meet those challenges. It's only your generosity that makes what we do possible. Please do what you can do. Today.
Now for today's column...
This year, I have been teaching a course on the Gospel of John at a local Roman Catholic parish. As one might expect, John's Gospel - with its depth and richness and outright mysteries - is not without its difficulties and challenges. For example, John 3:13: "No one has ascended into heaven but he who descended from heaven, the Son of Man." This is a good verse to contemplate in these final days before Christmas.
If the Son of Man referred to here is Jesus Christ, the second person of the Trinity, we can understand that He is the person spoken of. If, however, only the one who descended from Heaven can ascend into Heaven, how can anyone other than Jesus Christ ascend into Heaven? Since none of us, non-divine humans that we are, have descended from Heaven, are we then unable to ascend? What does this mean for the call to holiness? How can we be welcomed into the Kingdom of God?
The answer to this problem lies at the heart of the Gospel message, which St. Paul proclaims when he says in Galatians 2:20 that, through baptism, he has "been crucified with Christ; it is no longer I who live, but Christ who lives in me; and the life I now live in the flesh I live by faith in the Son of God, who loved me and gave himself for me."
It is only by becoming fully Christ-like as partakers of the mystical body that we can be "one in Christ" (Galatians 3:28), and those who ascend into Heaven are "heirs according to promise" (Galatians 3:29). To put off the old man and become another Christ (Ephesians 4:22), to have our old self crucified with Him (Romans 6:6), is a process that we might call Christification - that is, to "become" Christ.
I bring all this up because - not only is "becoming Christ" an important theme for me and my Gospel of John class - but the topic of Christification is the central theme, driving force, paradox, and solution in Fr. Robert Imbelli's book Christ Brings All Newness, published by Word on Fire Academic.
Throughout the book, Fr. Imbelli stresses the importance of setting Christ at the center of our life. We must find our source for living, not by any natural means, but through a ressourcement in Christ.
Re-Sourcement was one of the guiding principles at Vatican II. For Fr. Imbelli, it means going to that source of living water, which is eternal and becomes a wellspring within (John 4:14). Once we have returned to the source and we have become lamps burning and shining (John 5:35), we must go out and meet others where they are. We have a mission as Christians to cry out and spread the Good News (Mark 16:15) in a manner accessible to modern man, with all his errors and misconceptions. This new evangelization is also an aggiornamento (another key principle at the Council), the bringing of Christ the new Day (John 9:3-5).
Fr. Imbelli introduces early on the antithesis to the Christification of re-Sourcement and evangelization: what he calls the "excarnation."
Excarnation - a term which Fr. Imbelli adopts from the Catholic philosopher Charles Taylor - expresses the estrangement of modern humanity from its embodied and incarnational roots. It is the alienation of faith and spirituality from the tactile, sacramental, and relational aspects of life. Taylor's term underscores how modernity has favored a disembodied sense of self - one that views religion as abstract and private, disconnected from the communal and sacramental life of the Church.
In Imbelli's framework, excarnation is not merely a cultural shift but a spiritual crisis, one that has dulled the Christian imagina...