#253 ‒ Hormone replacement therapy and the Women’s Health Initiative: re-examining the results, the link to breast cancer, and weighing the risk vs reward of HRT | JoAnn Manson, M.D.

The Peter Attia Drive

View the Show Notes Page for This Episode

Become a Member to Receive Exclusive Content

Sign Up to Receive Peter’s Weekly Newsletter

JoAnn Manson is a world-renowned endocrinologist, epidemiologist, and Principal Investigator for the Women’s Health Initiative (WHI). In this episode, she dives deep into the WHI to explain the study design, primary outcome, confounding factors, and nuanced benefits and risks of hormone replacement therapy (HRT). JoAnn reflects on how a misinterpretation of the results, combined with sensationalized headlines regarding an elevated risk of breast cancer, led to a significant shift in the perception and utilization of HRT. From there, they take a closer look at the breast cancer data to separate fact from fiction. Additionally, JoAnn gives her take on how one should weigh the risks and benefits of HRT and concludes with a discussion on how physicians can move towards better HRT practices.

We discuss:

• The Women’s Health Initiative: the original goal of the study, hormone formulations used, and potential confounders [4:15];
• Study design of the Women’s Health Initiative, primary outcome, and more [16:00];
• JoAnn’s personal hypothesis about the ability of hormone replacement therapy to reduce heart disease risk prior to the WHI [26:45];
• The relationship between estrogen and breast cancer [30:45];
• Why the WHI study was stopped early, and the dramatic change in the perception and use of HRT due to the alleged increase in breast cancer risk [37:30];
• What Peter finds most troubling about the mainstream view of HRT and a more nuanced look at the benefits and risks of HRT [45:15];
• HRT and bone health [56:00];
• The importance of timing when it comes to HRT, the best use cases, and advice on finding a clinician [59:30];
• A discussion on the potential impact of HRT on mortality and a thought experiment on a long-duration use of HRT [1:03:15];
• Moving toward better HRT practices, and the need for more studies [1:10:00]; and
• More.

Connect With Peter on Twitter, Instagram, Facebook and YouTube